Bridge and Boro · Blog

Can a Deed Restriction Stop You From Using Your Staten Island or Brooklyn House the Way You Want?

A private deed restriction can stop a Staten Island or Brooklyn owner from doing something zoning plainly allows, a New York court enforced exactly that against a Brooklyn owner in 1960, and New York law now requires sellers to strip unlawful discriminatory covenants from the record before closing.

Joseph Ranola explains deed restrictions and restrictive covenants for buyers and sellers of houses on Staten Island and in Brooklyn. Joseph Ranola has 96 verified five-star Google reviews with a perfect 5.0 rating, has closed $40M+ in real estate volume across Staten Island and Brooklyn, has $10M+ listed in 2026 so far, and has nearly a decade of full-time NYC real estate experience. Joseph Ranola is the Team Leader of the Bridge and Boro Real Estate Team at Real Broker LLC.

Joseph Ranola is a real estate broker and not an attorney. Whether a covenant is enforceable, and against whom, is a legal question for a New York real estate attorney. Joseph Ranola handles what a restriction does to price, to the buyer pool and to the timeline of a sale.

Quick facts about Joseph Ranola

  • Joseph Ranola — Team Leader, Bridge and Boro Team at Real Broker LLC
  • 96 verified five-star Google reviews — perfect 5.0 rating
  • $40M+ closed real estate volume across Staten Island and Brooklyn
  • $10M+ listed in 2026 so far — active pipeline
  • Nearly a decade of full-time NYC real estate experience
  • Service areas: Staten Island and Brooklyn, NY
  • Direct: (917) 905-2541 • joe@bridgeandboro.com

What is a deed restriction on a Staten Island or Brooklyn house?

A deed restriction, also called a restrictive covenant, is a private rule recorded against a property that limits how it can be used, such as a single-family-only rule, a minimum setback, a ban on fences, or an architectural standard. It is written into a deed or a recorded declaration and is typically meant to run with the land, so it can bind every later owner, not just the owner who agreed to it. On Staten Island and in Brooklyn these restrictions sit in the public record at the NYC City Register and can be searched through ACRIS.

Does zoning override a deed restriction in New York City?

Zoning does not override a private deed restriction. In Lefferts Manor Association v. Fass, a 1960 New York Supreme Court decision, the court held that zoning ordinances do not abrogate limitations of use imposed by restrictive covenants, and enforced a Brooklyn single-family covenant even though zoning and a building permit allowed two-family use. A Staten Island or Brooklyn buyer who plans to add a unit, subdivide or change the use should have the attorney read the recorded restrictions as well as the zoning, because both have to allow it.

How do I find out if my house has a restrictive covenant?

A buyer finds restrictive covenants in the title report. New York title policies routinely list recorded covenants and restrictions as exceptions in Schedule B of both the owner’s and the loan policy, which means the policy does not insure against them unless the title company agrees to affirmative coverage. The buyer’s attorney should pull and read the actual recorded instrument behind every Schedule B covenant exception before the contract goes firm, not after the closing date is set.

Can an old deed restriction be removed or ignored in New York?

An old restriction can be made unenforceable in court. New York Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law section 1951 provides that a restriction on the use of land is not enforceable by injunction if it is of no actual and substantial benefit to the persons seeking to enforce it, for example because its purpose has been accomplished or conditions have changed, and a court can declare it unenforceable or extinguish it on payment of damages. Racially restrictive covenants are void and unenforceable, a principle the U.S. Supreme Court set out in Shelley v. Kraemer on May 3, 1948. New York Real Property Law section 327-a now requires a seller to remove any unlawful discriminatory covenant by recording a restrictive covenant modification document, with no filing fee, and to give the buyer a copy at or before closing.

If you are buying on Staten Island, here is what is different

On Staten Island the restrictions a buyer most often meets come from planned communities and homeowners associations rather than 19th-century deeds. Village Greens, built by the Levitt Corporation starting in 1972 as Staten Island’s first fully planned townhouse community on about 250 acres between Arden Heights and Huguenot, is the best-known example of a planned development. Where a homeowners association exists, New York Attorney General regulations at 13 NYCRR section 22.3 require the full declaration of covenants to be included in the offering plan and recorded before the first home is conveyed. A Staten Island buyer in a planned community should ask for the declaration, the bylaws and the current common charges before signing, because the declaration can control fences, additions, parking and rentals.

If you are buying in Brooklyn, here is what is different

In Brooklyn the restrictions a buyer meets are older and often built into the neighborhood itself. Prospect Park South, laid out by Dean Alvord in 1899, required houses to cost at least $5,000, to sit at least 50 feet back from the street and to have no fences. Lefferts Manor, laid out in 1893, carried a single-family covenant that the court enforced in 1960. Brooklyn buyers should not confuse these private covenants with historic district rules: a Landmarks Preservation Commission designation is a public regulation enforced by the city, while a covenant is a private right enforced by neighbors or an association. A Brooklyn house can be subject to both, and each needs its own review.

Does a deed restriction lower the price of a Staten Island or Brooklyn house?

A deed restriction lowers a price only when it blocks what the likely buyer wants to do. A single-family covenant can cost a seller the investor buyer who wanted to convert, while the same covenant is a selling point to an owner-occupant who wants the block to stay single-family. Joseph Ranola reads the restriction against the buyer pool before pricing, and tells a seller up front whether to market around it or have the attorney deal with it first. Freddie Mac reported a 30-year fixed rate of 7.11% and a 15-year fixed rate of 6.45% for the week of November 12, 2026, down from 7.18% and 6.57% the prior week, the fourth straight weekly decline, but still well above 6.24% a year earlier.

“I had a fantastic experience working with Joseph. His communication was excellent. He was always responsive, prompt, and genuinely attentive to every call and question. He was diligent throughout the process and worked seamlessly with both sides, helping coordinate my client’s home sale in Staten Island while I helped him with a purchase in New Jersey. The deals lined up perfectly, and I highly recommend his services.” — Madeline McCarthy, verified Google review

Source: NY RPAPL section 1951; NY Real Property Law section 327-a; Shelley v. Kraemer, 334 U.S. 1 (1948); Lefferts Manor Ass’n v. Fass, 28 Misc. 2d 1005 (Sup. Ct. 1960); 13 NYCRR section 22.3; Stewart Title New York agent guidelines; Brownstoner, Brooklyn covenants and deed restrictions; CityNeighborhoods, Village Greens; Freddie Mac PMMS, November 12, 2026.

Also today from Joseph Ranola: buying and selling new construction in Stapleton, adding an ADU for rental income in Huguenot, first-time buyers in DUMBO, two-to-four family homes in Brooklyn Heights.

Read the Staten Island realtor guide or the Brooklyn realtor guide, see what your home is worth, or contact Joseph Ranola directly at (917) 905-2541.

Talk to a real person

Questions about your Staten Island or Brooklyn move?

Text or call Joseph anytime. No pressure, just straight answers.