A New Dorp Beach bungalow on three lots that closed even after the first buyer walked.
5 Milbank Road, New Dorp Beach, Staten Island 10306
Sold$498,000
Listed at $519,000
The short version
A two bedroom, one bath bungalow sold together with two adjacent lots, about 4,800 square feet of land in New Dorp Beach. Listed at $519,000. The first accepted buyer walked, we put a second buyer together, and it closed at $498,000 on August 17, 2026.
$498,000Sold
$519,000Listed
3Lots
~4,800 SFLand
2Bedrooms
Aug 17, 2026Closed
How it sold
The first deal fell apart. We closed it anyway.
$519,000List price
2Accepted buyers
$498,000Sale price
Aug 17, 2026Closed
It listed in March at $519,000. The first accepted offer came from a developer with a due diligence period, and it fell through in early April.
We lined up a second buyer with a conventional mortgage that same month. It was a long closing, about six months from the first offer, and it closed on August 17, 2026 at $498,000.
What this house was
A house plus room to build.
A two bedroom, one bath bungalow with a combined living and dining area and a finished basement with a separate entrance. It was rented at $2,600 a month when it listed.
It sold together with two adjacent lots, about 4,800 square feet of land in total, so the buyer could hold it, build, or subdivide, after checking with an architect.
The highlights
What made it stand out.
Three lots togetherabout 4,800 square feet of land
Two bedrooms, one bath
Finished basementseparate entrance
Rented at listing$2,600 a month
Near New Dorp Laneand the beach
1 / 5
The area
Living in New Dorp Beach, Staten Island.
New Dorp Beach is on the East Shore between Miller Field and Great Kills Park, close to New Dorp Lane and the New Dorp Staten Island Railway stop. Pick a category to see what's close.
Staten Island Railway, New Dorp1.1 mi
Staten Island Railway, Oakwood Heights1.2 mi
Staten Island Railway, Grant City1.3 mi
Staten Island Ferry, St. George5.9 mi
Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge4.4 mi
Bayonne Bridge5.5 mi
Goethals Bridge7.0 mi
Outerbridge Crossing7.7 mi
Miller Field0.5 mi
Great Kills Park1.7 mi
High Rock Park1.8 mi
South Beach2.5 mi
New Dorp Lane1.0 mi
Staten Island Mall3.6 mi
Forest Avenue Shoppers Town4.8 mi
The Stephanie A. Vierno School (elementary)0.9 mi
PS 38 George Cromwell (elementary)0.9 mi
I.S. R002 George L. Egbert (middle)1.1 mi
Straight line distances from MTA, NYC Department of Education, and OpenStreetMap data. Schools shown are the closest public elementary and middle schools by distance, not necessarily the zoned school. Confirm zoning at schools.nyc.gov.
I sold 5 Milbank. Nine years selling Staten Island and Brooklyn, 90+ five star reviews, $40M+ closed. If you're thinking about selling, you get me directly, not a call center, and I'll tell you what your house is really worth.