November 21, 2026
Staten Island was the only New York City borough where the share of owner occupied homes went down between 2014 and 2024. According to a PropertyShark study of Census data, reported by the Staten Islander on November 19, the borough's owner occupied share slipped to 68%, which is still the highest in the city and above the national rate of 65%.
Watch on YouTube • Browse every Daily Tesla News episode
By share, yes. PropertyShark compared Census data from 2014 and 2024 across all 5 boroughs and 282 neighborhoods, and Staten Island was the only borough where the owner occupied share slipped, landing at 68%. A falling share does not necessarily mean fewer owners. It can also mean the number of rentals grew faster than the number of owner occupied homes, and the study points to new rental development as the driver of the shift.
Citywide, the number of owner occupied homes grew 11% over the same 10 years, faster than renter occupied homes at 6%. So the city as a whole moved slightly toward ownership while Staten Island moved the other way. Even after the slip, Staten Island's 68% owner occupied share is the highest of the 5 boroughs and above the national rate of 65%.
6 of the 10 NYC neighborhoods with the sharpest gains in renter share were on Staten Island. Stapleton led the list, up 22 percentage points to 77% renter occupied, as its number of rentals nearly doubled. The study ties the change to new rental development, which has been concentrated on the North Shore near the ferry.
Yes. Manor Heights, a neighborhood made up entirely of houses, went the other way. Its owner occupied share rose 11 points to 67%, which put it among the 10 biggest ownership gains in the city. That contrast is a big part of the story: the shift toward renting is happening in specific neighborhoods, not evenly across the borough.
It depends on who you ask. Supporters of new rental buildings say more apartments near the ferry give younger residents, workers and downsizers a place to live in the borough and can bring more foot traffic to local businesses. Critics worry about traffic, parking and infrastructure keeping up, and some residents see a lower ownership share as fewer long term stakeholders in a neighborhood. A city plan for up to 2,500 homes near the ferry is still in early review, so the trend may continue, and that debate is likely to continue with it.
The data points to a Staten Island that is splitting into a North Shore that is renting more and a mid and South Shore that is still mostly owners. For owners of small multifamily homes on the North Shore, more new rentals can mean more competition for tenants, but also a bigger pool of renters who may become buyers later. For sellers on the mid and South Shore, owner occupied homes remain the core of the market. Brooklyn, where most households rent, is a very different market, which is part of why Staten Island stands out as the borough where ownership is the norm. Whether the North Shore trend changes over the next 10 years will depend heavily on what gets approved near the ferry.
Questions about how this affects your home in Staten Island or Brooklyn? Work with Joseph Ranola, or text or call (917) 905-2541. New episodes of Daily Tesla News break down the NYC real estate stories that move the market.
Joseph Ranola and the Bridge and Boro Real Estate Team have closed $40M+ across both boroughs, backed by 87+ five-star Google reviews. Let’s talk about your goals.
Text or call (917) 905-2541 • joe@bridgeandboro.com
The questions people ask me when they're ready to act this month, answered straight.
It depends on the unit, the condition and what's renting nearby. Text Joe and I'll send you what similar places are getting.
Text Joe the word RENT at 917 905 2541
Run what you'd net from rent against what you'd walk away with from a sale. Text Joe and I'll give you both numbers.
Text Joe the word RENT at 917 905 2541
Compare your rent to what a mortgage payment would be and how long you plan to stay. Text Joe and I'll lay out both side by side.
Text Joe the word RENT at 917 905 2541
Priced right, many homes go into contract within a few weeks, then closing usually takes 60 to 90 days. Text Joe and I'll give you a timeline for yours.
Text or call Joseph anytime. No pressure, just straight answers.