Pleasant Plains, Staten Island (10309)

Your 2026 guide to buying or selling in Pleasant Plains.

Pleasant Plains is one of the quietest, most residential corners of Staten Island's far South Shore, full of detached single family homes, newer construction, and blocks close to the water and the SIR train. Whether you are listing your home or looking to buy in 10309, I help you move with real data and a plan. $40M+ closed, 87+ verified five star reviews, and a perfect 5.0 rating.

Selling in Pleasant Plains

Price sharp, market hard.

Far South Shore buyers know Pleasant Plains well, so a home in 10309 that is priced right and shown well gets attention fast. I set your number off recent sold comps in Pleasant Plains, then launch with pro photo, video, and full digital exposure built for AI search and real local buyers who want detached single family space near the water.

From your first walkthrough to the closing table, you get one point of contact and straight answers. Most of my listings see multiple offers because I price it right and market it hard from day one.

  • Pricing built from recent Pleasant Plains sold comps
  • Pro photo, video, and a full digital launch
  • AI search and SEO exposure so buyers find you
  • One point of contact from list to close
  • A clear net sheet so you know your bottom line

What's my home worth?

Or call/text Joseph directly at 917-905-2541

Got it. Joseph will personally review your home and reach out shortly.

Buying in Pleasant Plains

Find the right home, at the right number.

Pleasant Plains is a smart place to look for buyers who want a quiet, residential street with real space. The 10309 market runs from older detached homes worth updating to newer construction that is move in ready, and many blocks sit within easy reach of the water and the Pleasant Plains SIR train stop, with Tottenville and Prince's Bay right next door.

I pull comps before you tour, flag the homes actually worth your time, and negotiate hard so you do not overpay. You get honest guidance on condition, layout, and long term value on every home we see.

  • Comps pulled before every offer so you bid smart
  • Honest reads on condition, layout, and lot
  • Hard negotiation so you do not overpay
  • Guidance on financing, inspections, and closing
  • One trusted point of contact start to finish

Explore this neighborhood

Want the full local picture before you buy or sell in 10309? Read my in depth neighborhood guide.

Quick facts

  • Associate Broker and Team Leader of the Bridge and Boro Team at Real Broker LLC
  • 87+ verified five star Google reviews, perfect 5.0 rating
  • $40M+ closed across Staten Island and Brooklyn
  • Residential real estate across Staten Island and Brooklyn is all I do
  • Deep experience on the Staten Island far South Shore, including Pleasant Plains, Tottenville, and Prince's Bay
  • Serving Pleasant Plains (10309) and all of Staten Island and Brooklyn, NY

Pleasant Plains questions

Answers, up front.

What kind of homes are in Pleasant Plains (10309)?

Pleasant Plains is a quiet, residential pocket of the far South Shore built mostly around detached single family homes, with a healthy amount of newer construction mixed in among the older houses. You will find generous lots, private driveways, and blocks that sit within easy reach of the water. The 10309 ZIP draws families who want space, parking, and a calmer pace while staying close to the Pleasant Plains SIR train stop.

What do homes sell for in Pleasant Plains?

Prices move with condition, size, lot, and how close a home sits to the water, so I price every home from recent sold comps on the block rather than list prices. Older detached homes that need updating generally sit in a lower range, while newer construction and larger updated single family homes in 10309 reach a higher range. I will build you a current, specific to your address read before you list or make an offer.

How long does it take to sell in this part of Staten Island?

Well priced homes on the far South Shore often go into contract within the first two to three weeks. The key is sharp pricing from day one and a marketing launch that reaches real local buyers. I give you a realistic days on market read for your specific Pleasant Plains street before we list.

Do you help buyers as well as sellers in Pleasant Plains?

Yes. I represent both. For sellers I price sharp, market hard, and negotiate to net. For buyers I pull comps, spot the homes worth touring near the SIR train and the water, and negotiate hard so you do not overpay. Either way you get one point of contact and honest answers the whole way.

Or ask me anything else.

Real answers, free, no form. Even when the answer is: don't sell yet.

Thinking about Pleasant Plains?

Whether you are selling your far South Shore home or buying your next one in 10309, it starts with one quick conversation. Let's talk about your number and your plan.