Bridge and Boro · Blog

What’s the Truth About Seller Advantage? Staten Island 90-Day Market Check

December 1, 2025

What's the Truth About Seller Advantage? Staten Island 90-Day Market Check

The last 90 days continue to show a steady Staten Island market. No fireworks, no collapse, just a predictable environment where buyers who are serious act decisively and sellers who price correctly get rewarded.

There are 766 active single family listings on the market. Another 547 have accepted offers, and 663 closed in the past 90 days. That’s a healthy volume for this season.

The median active price sits at $724,500. That’s right in line with what you’d expect from Staten Island’s mid-market, showing consistency rather than volatility.

1

Pending homes are taking about 49 days to go under contract. That’s standard Q4 pacing. Buyers are not rushing, but they’re not dragging their feet either. They’re taking enough time to evaluate, then committing when the home is priced and positioned correctly.

Closed sellers finished with about 98.5% of their asking price. That number hasn’t budged much, and it tells you everything: the market still rewards accuracy, not wishful thinking.

  • For sellers, the formula is unchanged. Price where the data lives, prep the home properly, and the market will carry you to a clean outcome.

  • For buyers, selection is strong, but the best inventory still disappears quickly.

6

TLDR

  • 766 active

  • 547 pending

  • 663 closed

  • $724,500 median active

  • 49 days to contract

  • 98.5% of asking achieved

-

Joseph Ranola | Five-Star Staten Island & South Brooklyn Realtor® (90+ Google reviews)
Associate Broker · Real Broker LLC | Founder · Bridge and Boro Team
Serving 103xx and 11209 / 11214 / 11228 | $40M+ closed volume
📞 917-905-2541 | ranolarealestate.com

Check out this article next

What You Need to Know About Understanding NYC’s 800 Square Foot ADU Rule Under City of Yes

What You Need to Know About Understanding NYC’s 800 Square Foot ADU Rule Under City of Yes

One of the most important parts of the City of Yes ADU proposal is the size limit for new accessory units. The framework uses an…

Read Article

Ready to make a move?

The questions people ask me when they're ready to act this month, answered straight.

How long will it take to sell my Staten Island home?

Priced right, many homes go into contract within a few weeks, then closing usually takes 60 to 90 days. Text Joe and I'll give you a timeline for yours.

Text Joe the word SELL at 917 905 2541

What will it cost me to sell my house in Staten Island?

Selling in New York comes with transfer taxes, attorney fees and commission. Text Joe and I'll show you what you'd walk away with.

Text Joe the word SELL at 917 905 2541

How do I sell my house in Staten Island for the most money?

Price it right on day one, prep it well and market it to the right buyers. Text Joe and I'll show you the plan for your home.

Text Joe the word SELL at 917 905 2541

How fast are homes selling in Staten Island right now?

The well priced ones are moving. The overpriced ones sit. Text Joe and I'll show you what's happening on your block.

Text Joe the word SELL at 917 905 2541

Talk to a real person

Questions about your Staten Island or Brooklyn move?

Text or call Joseph anytime. No pressure, just straight answers.