July 18, 2026
A man named Juan Valoy posed as a legitimate New York City real estate broker and took roughly $105,000 from nearly two dozen prospective renters. He collected application fees, security deposits, and first month's rent on apartments he neither owned nor represented. He pleaded guilty in two separate cases and will serve at least four years. Before anything else, the important context: the overwhelming majority of brokers in this city are licensed, insured, and legitimate. This was one bad actor. But the damage one bad actor does to renters who are already stretched thin is real, so here is exactly how you protect yourself.
Watch on YouTube • Browse every Daily Tesla News episode
Juan Valoy presented himself as a legitimate New York City real estate broker and collected application fees, security deposits, and first month's rent from prospective tenants on apartments he did not own and did not represent. He pleaded guilty in two separate cases: roughly $25,000 taken from three victims in Manhattan, and $80,000 taken from eighteen victims in the Bronx. In total that is close to $105,000 from nearly two dozen renters. He will serve at least four years.
Use the New York State Department of State's free public license lookup. Every licensed real estate salesperson and broker in New York is searchable there by name. If the person you are dealing with does not appear in that database, or the name they gave you does not match what comes up, that is the end of the conversation. This takes about sixty seconds and it is the single most effective thing you can do.
A few show up again and again. The unit is priced meaningfully below market for the neighborhood. There is manufactured urgency, some version of "three other people are looking at it tonight, I need a deposit to hold it." You are asked to pay in cash, by wire, or through an untraceable payment app. You are asked for money before you have a signed lease. The person cannot or will not show you documentation that they have the right to rent the unit. And they are pushing you to skip steps you would normally take.
No. Never hand over a security deposit or first month's rent before you have a signed lease in your hand. That signed lease is what ties the money you paid to an actual apartment and an actual landlord. Paying first and signing later is precisely the gap these scams live in. Pay by a traceable method, get a receipt, and keep every message.
Under New York City's FARE Act, the party who hires the broker pays the broker. In practice, when a landlord lists an apartment through a broker, the landlord pays that fee rather than passing it to the tenant. That matters for scam detection: someone calling themselves a broker who demands a large fee directly from you as a renter is going against how the market now works, and that should raise your guard rather than feel like a normal cost of doing business.
Stop sending money immediately and save everything: text messages, emails, listing screenshots, payment receipts, and any documents they sent you. File a report with the NYPD and with the New York State Department of State, which licenses and disciplines real estate professionals. If you paid by a traceable method, contact your bank or the payment provider right away, because speed matters for any chance of recovery. And tell people, because these operations run on the same listings and the same script across many victims.
Questions about how this affects your home in Staten Island or Brooklyn? Work with Joseph Ranola, or text or call (917) 905-2541. New episodes of Daily Tesla News break down the NYC real estate stories that move the market.
Joseph Ranola and the Bridge and Boro Real Estate Team have closed $40M+ across both boroughs, backed by 80+ five-star Google reviews. Let’s talk about your goals.
Text or call (917) 905-2541 • joe@bridgeandboro.com
Text or call Joseph anytime. No pressure, just straight answers.