A quiet neighborhood at the island's southern tip in ZIP 10307 near Tottenville and Mount Loretto - larger lots, open space, and a true edge-of-the-city feel. Here is what it is actually like to live here.
Butler Manor sits at the very southern tip of Staten Island near Tottenville, a quiet, low-density neighborhood of detached single-family homes, some on notably larger lots. It has a peaceful, tucked-away character right at the edge of the city.
The Mount Loretto Unique Area's meadows and shoreline are right nearby, offering rare open space and waterfront, and Tottenville's Main Street and SIR terminal are a short drive. For buyers who want room, quiet, and nature at the island's edge, Butler Manor is a hidden pocket.
Rare open meadows and protected shoreline right nearby.
Detached homes, some on generous parcels.
The railway terminal and Main Street a short drive away.
The island's peaceful southern tip.
Butler Manor is a quiet, low-density South Shore market. Most homes typically trade around $600,000 to $1.1M depending on lot size, home size, and condition, with larger-lot properties at the top. Buyers who want room and quiet at the island's edge keep steady interest.
Those are ranges, not your number. The only way to know what a specific Butler Manor home is worth today is a real read on the exact house and the most recent sales on its block.
Butler Manor is a quiet neighborhood at Staten Island's southern tip in ZIP 10307 near Tottenville and Mount Loretto, known for larger lots, open space, and an edge-of-the-city feel.
Most homes in Butler Manor typically trade around $600K - $1.1M depending on size, lot, condition, and block, with detached single-family homes, some larger lots in the mix. For a current price on a specific home, request a free valuation from Joseph Ranola.
Butler Manor is a quiet, low-density, nature-adjacent neighborhood at the island's southern tip. Residents value the larger lots, Mount Loretto's open space, and the peaceful edge-of-the-city setting.
Butler Manor runs on cars and buses with the Tottenville Staten Island Railway terminal a short drive away, running north to the ferry.
I work this market every week. Whether you are pricing your home or chasing the right one, let's talk about your block specifically.