‹ Back to listings
Sold · Detached Dutch colonial

A Randall Manor Dutch colonial with a saltwater pool that had multiple offers within about 36 hours.

84 Elwood Place, Randall Manor, Staten Island 10301
Sold$1,200,000
Listed at $1,174,000 · $26,000 over ask
The short version

A detached four bedroom Dutch colonial in Randall Manor with a heated saltwater pool and a pool house. Listed at $1,174,000, it drew at least three offers within about 36 hours, signed at $1,200,000 the day after launch, and closed on July 15, 2026.

$1,200,000Sold
$1,174,000Listed
+$26,000Over ask
4Bedrooms
~36 hrsOffers in
Jul 15, 2026Closed
How it sold

Three offers in about a day and a half, and $26,000 over ask.

$1,174,000List price
$1,200,000Sale price
3+Offers in ~36 hours
Jul 15, 2026Closed

It hit the market April 2 and 3 at $1,174,000. A full price offer came in on April 3, and by that evening there was a third offer on the table.

On April 4 the buyer came up to $1,200,000 with 30 percent down, and that's the one the sellers signed. It closed on July 15, 2026, $26,000 over the asking price.

What this house was

A Dutch colonial with a backyard you don't leave.

A designer kitchen flows into formal living and dining rooms, and a sunlit office with a wall of windows sits off the living room. Four bedrooms, including a finished upper level space that works as a guest room, office, or retreat. Laundry is on the second floor, and the full basement is finished with a separate side entrance.

Out back: a heated saltwater in-ground pool with a waterfall, a pool house with virtual golf, an oversized balcony overlooking the yard, and full landscaping. Four zone heat, central air, and a driveway.

The highlights

What made it stand out.

Heated saltwater poolwith a waterfall
Pool housewith virtual golf
Designer kitcheninto formal living and dining
Sunlit officeoff the living room
Second floor laundry
Finished basementseparate side entrance
Four zone heatplus central air
Oversized balconyover the yard
Photo 1 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 2 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 3 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 4 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 5 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 6 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 7 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 8 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 9 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 10 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 11 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 12 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 13 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 14 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 15 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 16 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 17 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 18 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 19 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 20 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 21 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 22 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 23 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island Photo 24 of 84 Elwood Place in Randall Manor, Staten Island
1 / 24
The area

Living in Randall Manor, Staten Island.

Randall Manor is on the North Shore, a quiet tree lined pocket near Silver Lake Park, Clove Lakes Park, and the restaurants and shops on Forest Avenue. Pick a category to see what's close.

Staten Island Railway, Tompkinsville1.5 mi
Staten Island Railway, Stapleton1.5 mi
Staten Island Railway, St George1.7 mi
Staten Island Ferry, St. George1.7 mi

Straight line distances from MTA, NYC Department of Education, and OpenStreetMap data. Schools shown are the closest public elementary and middle schools by distance, not necessarily the zoned school. Confirm zoning at schools.nyc.gov.

Property at a glance

Pick what you want to see.

Detached Dutch colonialProperty type
4Bedrooms
Finished, separate side entranceBasement
Answers

What people asked about this house.

What did 84 Elwood Place sell for?

$1,200,000, which was $26,000 over the $1,174,000 asking price. It closed on July 15, 2026.

How many offers were there?

At least three within about 36 hours of hitting the market.

What's my North Shore home worth?

Text Joe your address at 917 905 2541 and he'll tell you what this sale means for your number.

Selling nearby?

Want to know what this sale means for your house?

Text me your address. I'll tell you straight what 84 Elwood does to your number, no pitch.

Joseph Ranola
Associate Broker and Team Leader

I sold 84 Elwood. Nine years selling Staten Island and Brooklyn, 90+ five star reviews, $40M+ closed. If you're thinking about selling, you get me directly, not a call center, and I'll tell you what your house is really worth.

For agents showing this home

Enter your code.

That code didn't work.