35 Milbank Road – New Dorp Beach, Staten Island
2
BEDROOMS
1
BATHROOM
560
SQ FT
20×60
LOT SIZE
1930
BUILT
$2,019
ANNUAL TAXES
Fully Renovated Cottage in New Dorp Beach
Welcome to 35 Milbank Road — a charming single-story cottage that has been completely renovated from top to bottom. This 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom home offers 560 square feet of thoughtfully updated living space, sitting on a 20×60 lot in one of Staten Island’s most beloved coastal neighborhoods.
Modern Finishes Throughout
Every inch of this home has been updated with care. The brand-new kitchen features white shaker cabinetry, a subway tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances, and a sleek peninsula island with a matte black faucet — perfect for casual dining and entertaining. The updated bathroom showcases a striking navy blue vanity with a marble-look tile surround, a modern tub/shower combo, and an LED-lit mirror. New light oak hardwood floors flow throughout the home, complemented by a brand-new roof, gutters, doors, and light fixtures.
The Neighborhood
New Dorp Beach is a quiet, tight-knit coastal community on Staten Island’s East Shore. Known for its proximity to the beach and the bay, residents enjoy a relaxed pace of life with easy access to the boardwalk, local parks, and the New Dorp SIR station for a quick commute to the ferry. Shopping, dining, and everyday conveniences are just minutes away along Hylan Boulevard and New Dorp Lane.
Key Features
Fully Renovated
Top-to-bottom renovation: new kitchen, bath, floors, roof, gutters, doors & fixtures
Designer Kitchen
White shaker cabinets, subway tile, stainless appliances & peninsula island
Beach Living
Steps from New Dorp Beach, the boardwalk, and the bay
Classic Bungalow
Single-story cottage charm built in 1930 with tasteful modern updates
Low Taxes
Just $2,019/year — one of the lowest tax bills on the market
$399,000
Priced to move — schedule your private showing today
Financial Details
Price
$399,000
Bedrooms
2
Bathroom
1
Sq Ft
560
Year Built
1930
Annual Taxes
$2,019
New Dorp Beach: Coastal Staten Island Living
New Dorp Beach is one of Staten Island’s most charming coastal neighborhoods, offering a rare blend of beachside tranquility and suburban convenience. Nestled along the East Shore, residents enjoy direct access to the waterfront, the historic boardwalk, and Gateway National Recreation Area — all while being minutes from the shops and restaurants along New Dorp Lane and Hylan Boulevard.
The New Dorp SIR station puts Manhattan within easy reach via the Staten Island Railway and ferry, making it an ideal location for commuters who want the peace of coastal living without sacrificing city access. Whether you are a first-time buyer, downsizer, or investor, New Dorp Beach delivers exceptional value in one of Staten Island’s most desirable ZIP codes.
Take a Virtual Tour
For New Dorp Beach Homeowners
Curious what your home would attract?
The Milbank Road block is having a moment. Two homes here just went under contract within weeks. The buyers we turned away are still actively looking in this exact pocket of New Dorp Beach. If you’ve ever wondered what your home would attract in today’s market, even just out of curiosity, request a no-pressure home value report. Delivered in 24 hours. No calls unless you ask.
70+ five-star Google reviews · Bridge & Boro Team · Real Broker
Let’s Open The Door
The Bridge and Boro Team
Real Broker LLC
About Your Listing Agent
Joseph (Joe) Ranola
Associate Broker & Team Leader | The Bridge and Boro Team at Real Broker LLC
A Staten Island native with nearly a decade of real estate experience, Joe Ranola knows New Dorp Beach and the surrounding East Shore communities inside and out. He has closed multiple deals in this neighborhood and across the South Shore, from New Dorp Lane to Cedar Grove. With 70+ five-star Google reviews and 50+ happy clients, his track record speaks for itself — and the majority of his business comes from referrals and repeat clients. See Joe’s sold listings →
Joe treats every listing like his own home. From pre-listing preparation and professional staging guidance to premium photography, immersive virtual tours, and targeted digital marketing campaigns, he ensures every property gets the attention it deserves. He has broken multiple pricing records across Staten Island and consistently helps homeowners maximize their property value through strategic pricing and expert negotiation.
Whether you are buying your first home in New Dorp Beach, selling a bungalow near the water, or investing in one of Staten Island’s most promising coastal neighborhoods, Joe brings the local knowledge, market expertise, and personalized attention that gets deals done at the best possible price.
Thinking of selling in New Dorp Beach? Call Joe at 917-905-2541 or email [email protected] for a free, no-obligation home valuation.